Chapter 27 - Of Rites, Ceremonies and Things Indifferent
CEREMONIES AND RITES. Unto the ancient people were given at one time certain
ceremonies, as a kind of instruction for those who were kept under the law, as
under a schoolmaster or tutor. But when Christ, the Deliverer, came and the law
was abolished, we who believe are no more under the law (Rom. 6:14), and the
ceremonies have disappeared; hence the apostles did not want to retain or to
restore them in Christ's Church to such a degree that they openly testified that
they did not wish to impose any burden upon the Church. Therefore, we would seem
to be bringing in and restoring Judaism if we were to increase ceremonies and
rites in Christ's Church according to the custom in the ancient Church. Hence,
we by no means approve of the opinion of those who think that the Church of
Christ must be held in check by many different rites, as if by some kind of
training. For if the apostles did not want to impose upon Christian people
ceremonies or rites which were appointed by God, who, I pray, in his right mind
would obtrude upon them the inventions devised by man? The more the mass of
rites is increased in the Church, the more is detracted not only from Christian
liberty, but also from Christ, and from faith in him, as long as the people seek
those things in ceremonies which they should seek in the only Son of God, Jesus
Christ, through faith. Wherefore a few moderate and simple rites, that are not
contrary to the Word of God, are sufficient for the godly.
DIVERSITY OF RITES. If different rites are found in churches, no one should
think that for this reason the churches disagree. Socrates says: "It would be
impossible to put together in writing all the rites of churches throughout
cities and countries. No religion observes the same rites, even though it
embraces the same doctrine concerning them. For those who are of the same faith
disagree among themselves about rites" (Hist. ecclesiast. V.22, 30, 62). This
much says Socrates. And we, today, having in our churches different rites in the
celebration of the Lord's Supper and in some other things, nevertheless do not
disagree in doctrine and faith; nor is the unity and fellowship of our churches
thereby rent asunder. For the churches have always used their liberty in such
rites, as being things indifferent. We also do the same thing today.
THINGS INDIFFERENT. But at the same time we admonish me to be on guard lest they
reckon among things indifferent what are in fact not indifferent, as some are
wont to regard the mass and the use of images in places of worship as things
indifferent. "Indifferent," wrote Jerome to Augustine, "is that which is neither
good nor bad, so that, whether you do it or not, you are neither just nor
unjust." Therefore, when things indifferent are wrested to the confession of
faith, they cease to be free; as Paul shows that it is lawful for a man to eat
flesh if someone does not remind him that it was offered to idols; for then it
is unlawful, because he who eats it seems to approve idolatry by eating it (I
Cor. 8:9 ff.; 10:25 ff.).